<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
	<rss version="2.0"
		xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
		xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
		xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
		xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"

			>

	<channel>

		<title>Sci Fi SadGeezers &#187; All Posts</title>
		<atom:link href="https://sadgeezer.com/forums/forum/cult-sci-fi-series/dune/feed/" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
		<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/forum/cult-sci-fi-series/dune/feed/</link>
		<description></description>
		<lastBuildDate>Sat, 15 Mar 2025 04:19:24 +0000</lastBuildDate>
		<generator>https://bbpress.org/?v=2.6.12</generator>
		<language>en-GB</language>

		
		
					
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-region-b-blu-ray-release-2012-some-comments/#post-78134</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[ Funny you should say that.]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-region-b-blu-ray-release-2012-some-comments/#post-78134</link>
					<pubDate>Sun, 17 Mar 2013 00:54:44 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>SadGeezer</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>&nbsp;Funny you should say that. &nbsp;I actually did a piece on LEXX Makers:</p>
<p><a href="http://sadgeezer.com/LEXX-Makers-Production-Stuff.htm">sadgeezer.com/LEXX-Makers-Production-Stuff.htm</a></p>
<p>It was mostly written in the mid to late 90&#8217;s after I&#8217;d met some of the designers and writers of the show. &nbsp;At the time, I managed a Multimedai Centre in blackburn in the UK and knew a little about what was being done. &nbsp;Yes, there was so much CGI in LEXX and the computer screens of the age weren&#8217;t much better in terms of resolution than smart phones today. &nbsp;</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-region-b-blu-ray-release-2012-some-comments/#post-78130</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[If it was shot on film with]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-region-b-blu-ray-release-2012-some-comments/#post-78130</link>
					<pubDate>Thu, 28 Feb 2013 20:15:28 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>fisk0</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>If it was shot on film with &quot;practical effects&quot;, i.e. miniatures and animatronics, I think I&#8217;d opt for the Blu-ray release, but stuff like LEXX was shot for TV, with CGI that was probably not rendered in higher resolution than necessary for SD TV broadcasting back in the late 90&#8217;s. I&#8217;m not sure, but I think they probably used digital or video cameras rather than film stock for that one.&nbsp; Seems like the new Star&nbsp;Trek:&nbsp;The Next&nbsp;Generation blu-rays are fantastic, due to the fact that it was shot on film and mostly used miniature effects, though there was some use of low res digital editing and compositing&nbsp; that made the TV&nbsp;prints unusable for bluray, but as they had the film stock they could recomposite and re-edit that with HD quality effects again.</p>
<p>I&#8217;m not sure about Babylon 5, looks to me like it was shot on film (I could be mistaken though), but since most of the effects were CGI, and they&#8217;ve lost the original files, they&#8217;d have to recreate and rerender all that from scratch again. Sounds doable to me, but would probably be much more expensive than the process was for TNG.</p>
<p>Even if it was shot on film with a lot of practical effects, like most of Dune was, there&#8217;s the risk that they botch up the transfer from film to HD too, like I feel like they did with this Dune release, so I&#8217;m not sure there is much general advice I could give.</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-region-b-blu-ray-release-2012-some-comments/#post-78121</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[ Yep.  I guess i&#8217;ll hold off]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-region-b-blu-ray-release-2012-some-comments/#post-78121</link>
					<pubDate>Thu, 07 Feb 2013 17:01:39 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>SadGeezer</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>&nbsp;Yep. &nbsp;I guess i&#8217;ll hold off buying t his on Bluray. &nbsp;Thanks for the review.</p>
<p>i just wonder though, if people are considering upgrading their fave DVD collections of shows and films to Bluray? &nbsp;I&#8217;ve decided to start doing that wil fave&#8217;s like LotR, Matrix and Harry Potter, but not sure I&#8217;d go for upgrading Babylon 5 or LEXX for the same reasons you mention above. &nbsp;I suspect that the tech for production of TV shows doesn&#8217;t lend itself to 1080p and above resolution.</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-region-b-blu-ray-release-2012-some-comments/#post-41315</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[Dune region B blu-ray release (2012), some comments]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-region-b-blu-ray-release-2012-some-comments/#post-41315</link>
					<pubDate>Fri, 31 Aug 2012 19:34:13 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>fisk0</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>&nbsp;So, as my old VHS copy had gotten pretty worn out, and as now when I have a bluray player I thought it might be uneccessary to get the DVD when there had just been a bluray release &#8211; I bought the 2012 region B bluray version of Dune (product code BLU-RAY 828 880 6 &#8211; 11, EAN 5 050582 888065).</p>
<p>It is a beautiful movie, but the quality of this bluray print was below expectations, there were some scenes with very noticeable compression issues, and much of the movie looked like it was just the DVD print&nbsp;upscaled to HD resolution. I assume that when they put the DVD versions together many years ago they made a digital transfer at slightly above the standard DVD resolution of the day, but not quite at the resolutions that are considered HD today, but it&#8217;s of course also possible that they actually did a full HD transfer from film, but&nbsp;just used some overly intrusive methods for cleaning up the footage that cause noticeable digital artifacts. Some scenes (especially daylight outdoors scenes, like the desert vistas) look pretty crisp and detailed, but most night shots look terrible, with very noticeable pixelation and color depth issues. I have no complaints regarding the sound quality, but I would&#8217;ve expected a bit more from a 2012 HD release.</p>
<p>I know there are plenty of other bluray editions of the movie, mostly german prints of the TV extended edit. I haven&#8217;t seen those prints, so I can&#8217;t compare with that, nor with the old DVD release, I&#8217;ve only got my old VHS to compare with, and kinda feel like many close shots look better there than on this bluray version.</p>
<p>Kinda hard to recommend, especially at the current price, but as new releases tend to be rather expensive &nbsp;but drop in price in 6 months or so, it might be worth to pick up then.</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-epsiodes/#post-76569</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[Re:Dune Epsiodes?]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-epsiodes/#post-76569</link>
					<pubDate>Tue, 18 Jul 2006 20:57:06 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>nexus6</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>Hope so, but I haven&#8217;t heard anything. I would be awsome if they took it back to the beginning and do The Butlarian Jihad, The Machine Crusade and The Battle for Corrin.</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-epsiodes/#post-40901</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[Dune Epsiodes?]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/dune-epsiodes/#post-40901</link>
					<pubDate>Mon, 17 Jul 2006 19:31:21 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>SadGeezer</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>Are there any more Dune episodes planned?</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/my-new-forum/#post-75681</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[Scytale lives!]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/my-new-forum/#post-75681</link>
					<pubDate>Thu, 01 Dec 2005 12:21:04 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>Scytale</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>Hi Muad&#8217;Dib!</p>
<p>It was this moniker &#8211; Scytale. since there don&#8217;t appear to be any other cosmic entities posting I was a bit surprised!</p>
<p>In fact, I might even see it as an Atreides  plot against the poor, maligned and presciently persecuted Bene Tleilax; of which of course I am the sole surviving member! You of the House of Alpha-Male Atreus were always stepping on us poor hermaphrodites!</p>
<p>but hearken Paul, the REAL story of what happened has now been written by me! You can read it at:</p>
<p><a href="http://www.freewebs.com/scytale" rel="nofollow">http://www.freewebs.com/scytale</a></p>
<p>(seriously, the novel is a fan fiction tribute to Frank Herbert&#8217;s vision, covering the chronology of the six DUNE novels from just prior to DUNE MESSIAH to just beyond the conclusion of CHAPTERHOUSE: DUNE. If you do read it I hope you enjoy reading it as much as I did the writing! Very best regards,</p>
<p>Scytale)</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/my-new-forum/#post-75678</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[Re:My new forum]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/my-new-forum/#post-75678</link>
					<pubDate>Thu, 01 Dec 2005 07:39:10 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>MuadDib</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>I&#8217;d completly forgotten about that  😀  What name did you try?</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/my-new-forum/#post-75672</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[Re: My new forum]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/my-new-forum/#post-75672</link>
					<pubDate>Wed, 30 Nov 2005 16:01:14 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>Scytale</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>[quote=&#8221;MuadDib&#8221;]Not stealing the sadgeezer limelight or anything, but I have created my own little dune-centric forum at: [url]http://foldspace.proboards39.com[/url] please check it out when your in the neighbourhood[/quote]</p>
<p>Hi, I did register and try to post but it told me my confirmed username was already in use? Not to worry &#8211; a great idea!</p>
<p>Scytale</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/scytale-lives/#post-40695</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[Scytale lives!]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/scytale-lives/#post-40695</link>
					<pubDate>Wed, 30 Nov 2005 15:41:25 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>Scytale</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>Dear fellow Duneophiles, Spice Girls and diehard avant-gardes and Herbertians,</p>
<p>Scytale the Face Dancer here. Having escaped the less-than-feminine clutches of the Bene Gesserit Sisterhood (who impiously and rudely took me prisoner in CHAPTERHOUSE: DUNE) and made my way to a mysterious neutral planet I felt it was time for me to answer the calumnies and abuse that have been heaped upon the Tleilaxu by the fanatical infidel propaganda machine of those prescient pinheads, the Atreides! All who care to read the real truth may find it in my entertainingly nefarious and despicable memoirs at:</p>
<p><a href="http://www.freewebs.com/scytale" rel="nofollow">http://www.freewebs.com/scytale</a></p>
<p>(Seriously, a fan fiction novel of Scytale’s adventures having no connection with Frank Herbert’s incomparable work. As an aspiring science fiction writer I’m keen to get feedback on it and if you do read the short novel I hope you enjoy it as much as I did the writing! Best regards, Scytale)</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/you-know-youre-a-dune-fanatic-when/#post-75671</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[Re:You know you&#8217;re a Dune fanatic when&#8230;]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/you-know-youre-a-dune-fanatic-when/#post-75671</link>
					<pubDate>Wed, 30 Nov 2005 15:39:06 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>Scytale</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>You really know you&#8217;re a Duneophile when:</p>
<p>You think the SPICE GIRLS are an Arrakeen dancing troupe!</p>
<p>(I too have tried&#8230;)</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

			
				<item>
					<guid>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/stone-burner-as-sf-sci-fi-uber-weapon/#post-75203</guid>
					<title><![CDATA[Re:Stone Burner as sf/sci-fi über weapon??]]></title>
					<link>https://sadgeezer.com/forums/topic/stone-burner-as-sf-sci-fi-uber-weapon/#post-75203</link>
					<pubDate>Tue, 26 Jul 2005 07:43:12 +0000</pubDate>
					<dc:creator>7th_Dizbuster</dc:creator>

					<description>
						<![CDATA[
						<p>All these posts focus on what creates the biggest bang, be that explosion or implosion.  For me it is not bang per buck but cause and after effect that creates the ultimate weapon.  This has to be the small lump of metal that was dropped out of hyperspace in Juggernaut by A E van Vogt.</p>
<p>This metal had qualities that made it workable, for a time, but then became indestructable and when brought into contact with other metals it passed those qualities on.  To cut a short stroy even shorter: tanks and aircraft made of the metal were unstoppable but the metal found its way into the armory and shells and bombs stopped exploding, the enemy&#8217;s metal store was contaminated so also became imune.  Eventually there was only one metal on the whole planet.  End of war, all war, and industry and &#8230;&#8230;.</p>
<p>This story appeared in Astounding in 1944.  No I am not that old, I have The Best of A E van Vogt.  I took it as a moral such as &#8220;be careful what you wish for, you might just get it.&#8221;</p>
						]]>
					</description>

					
					
				</item>

					
		
	</channel>
	</rss>

